The Dark Knight – American League East

by Paul Raymond | Posted on Wednesday, July 23rd, 2008

The Dark Knight - MLB American League EastNOTE: IF YOU HAVE NOT SEEN THE DARK KNIGHT YET, YOU MAY WANT TO AVOID READING THIS DUE TO SPOILERS. With that being said, I’ve waited a few days to write this article to give as many of you as possible a chance to see the movie. After seeing this movie a weird thought popped in to my head at how this movie reminds me so much of the American League East. You’ve got a hero and a villain who are so evenly matched and understand each other so well. You’ve got a simple man who comes out of no where to become a very influential person in the city. And a slew of other characters that make the movie go. In all honesty, I could have made this article with all American League contenders there is just that many good compelling characters. But I decided to keep it simple so without further ado here is the cast for the The Dark Knight – American League East:

Toronto Blue Jays as Lt. James Gordon
– The Blue Jays have been a team on a roller coaster ride much like Lt. Gordon. They’ve gone from trying to find an identity, to being an outstanding team, to disappearing once again, and look here the team is fighting its way back into contention. How does this compare to Gordon? Well beginning of the movie he’s got his hands full, fighting the mob, a new threat in the Joker and trying to work with new District Attorney Harvey Dent. Not everything is going right but he’s fighting, and doing his best enough to keep a float (month of April). Then after that with the help of Batman, Lau is taken down and the mob crumbles things are going great (the outstanding May). After that, people start dying around him and he’s forced to fake his own death, hurt the ones he loves as not a soul knows (the team disappearing in June). But at the end, he’s back he saves Batman and catches the Joker, things couldn’t be better and a promotion is in the works, he’s loved by many (fighting back into contention in July). While there is more after this, you can see how this in a way mirrors the Blue Jays season. The question is thou, can the Blue Jays disappear then elevate to the top post in the division? The answer is a NO, the odds are just to hard. BUT there will be some kind of position change, much like there was for now Commissioner Gordon. This will come in the firing of J.P. Ricciardi in the off-season and a new General Manager brought in.

Baltimore Orioles as The Scarecrow – The Orioles much like the Scarecrow only had a brief appearance in the movie. The team shot out of the gates but then began to play well like the Orioles. As I write this I’m laughing with the picture in my head. In the scene, the one mobster is complaining to the Scarecrow after how his clients are so crazy after buying his drug, and can’t become repeat customers because they’re too crazy. Well you know what, isn’t this just like the Orioles??? Their product in this case is so bad that it scares the fans away and kills any chance at repeat business.

Tampa Bay Rays as Harvey Dent / Two-Face
– Harvey Dent represented the good in Gotham, he represented hope according to Batman he was the true hero, the hero Gotham needed. Well look at the Rays, they’ve been the doormat of the AL East for years, they’re winning, bringing the city of Tampa hope and even all of baseball hope. The hope that the Yankees and Red Sox can both, be overtaken at the top of that division. If they do that, they are without a doubt a hero. The question is when tragedy strikes which Rays team are we going to get? Will they continue to be heroes or the team that only has a 50/50 chance of winning on any given night. We will find out as tragedy almost struck right before the All-Star break, in the tune of a 7 game losing streak that let the Red Sox and Yankees both storm back into the race. At the end of the movie, Harvey Dent was remembered as a hero for all he did, not what he became. Like he said, “you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain”. Well he became the villain but his friends chose to remember him otherwise. At the end of this season, even if they miss the playoffs, the Rays will be remembered as a hero by many because of all the hope they gave this year and for the future.

Boston Red Sox as the Joker – This makes perfect sense as the Joker is brilliantly psychotic. The Red Sox can you get any more psychotic then that clubhouse? I know the Yankees have A-Rod / Madonna, and Jason Giambi wearing thongs, but look at the Sox? They’ve got players fighting in the dugout, a player pushing team personnel to the ground, players almost getting arrested while leaving the game for ignoring police officers. They’ve got a closer who dances crazy, and their bullpen duo has their own Milli Vanilli impersonation video. The team is simply psychotic but when it comes time for business it all meshes together and is a complete terror on anyone they play. The joker is driven by revenge, mainly due to the cruel life he endured. The Red Sox maybe not be driven by revenge but their fans definitely are. They want to win every year. They want to exorcise all the demons from that 86 year stretch of misery. No matter how many championships they win, they will always be out for revenge when it comes to the Yankees for all those years of cruelty. In the movie, the Joker gets caught, gets out to fight again and then he’s caught again. Well we all know the Red Sox are fighters they fall behind, they fight back, they may slump again but then they fight back even harder. The Red Sox even with all their craziness do love to have fun. I think their question to the Yankees should be like the Jokers to Batman, “Why So Serious?”

New York Yankees as Batman – No surprise here, I’m a Yankees fan so they get the role as the hero. Looking at this movie thou, Batman is no hero at least in public opinion. By the end of the story, everyone wants Batman dead and you know what EVERY YEAR that’s what people want of the Yankees. Every year they think that time is now but the team comes fighting back and the status quo is maintained. In the movie, Batman is run off as people look to catch him for the murders of Gotham’s finest, but is their any doubt that he continues to return and fight against the underbelly of Gotham. The one line in the movie thou will make any person agree that the Yankees take the role of Batman. Christian Bale says “Batman has no limits”. Well everyone knows the Yankees have “no limits”. This decade the Yankees have spent whatever money it’s taken to get the players they felt the needed. Much like Batman, their reach isn’t just local either. To take care of business they’ll go anywhere. Batman had to take a trip to Hong Kong to bring down the mob. Well the Yankees have gone to Japan and Taiwan for some of their key players. Again, at the end of the movie, Batman was run off but you know he will be back to fight again. If somehow the Yankees do indeed miss the playoffs you know they will be back.

If you’re a Sox or Yanks fan it’s pretty obvious which team you’d choose as the Joker. I’m a Yankees fan so obviously the Red Sox are the villain. No one else can be considered for these two roles, as they are the perfect compliment to each other. At every turn the Joker is there trying to expose the Batman for what he is, a fraud. Well Red Sox fans are always trying to expose the Yankees as frauds, attempting to say all titles are bought. But in reality both teams, and Batman/Joker are more alike then anyone wants to believe. They both spend insane amounts of money. They both have their own psychotic tendencies in the clubhouse. They both have insanely passionate fans. The Joker and Batman both have had trouble pasts and because of that understand each other more then any other person. The Sox and Yankees mirror each other so much (minus championship totals) that they know each other better then anyone. And in both cases, movie and baseball that is what’s created such a terrific rivalries, the best in sports and arguably the best in comics.

Displaying 29 Comments
Add Your Comment
  1. atthehive says:


    Man, this is absolute genius. I’m a Yankee fan as well, so I must commend your role casting.

    That movie was so awesome I might go see it again…

  2. Neil says:

    Your Yankees are starting to play the role of Batman on the baseball field. They are quickly moving up the standings and creeping up on Boston and Tampa. Huge series against the Sox this weekend.

    Also, The Dark Knight was pure genious.

  3. James says:

    Great Movie, great article. How about my Royals playing Alfred?

  4. Paul Raymond says:

    I could see that James, but I’m not to sure. Because the day the Yankees reach their limits, the Royals are going to be jumping for joy.

  5. Cubbie Blue says:

    Nice article, hope “Batman” dies at the end of the sequel!

  6. Jeff says:

    Tampa Bay Rays are located in St. Petersburg, a large city. Tampa is about 30 minutes North-Northeast, just so you know.

  7. Pmick24 says:

    very nice work…but from now on, have someone proof read for you, and use spell check. thanks

  8. Turtle says:

    Well, as a Red Sox fan i was at first not happy at the notion of the Red Sox being portrayed as The Villain. But after reading the comparisons of team-to-character, 2 things stood out to me

    1) the author of this article needs to use a spell & grammar check for his articles
    2) i agree with the Joker-to-Red Sox and Yankees-to-Batman comparisons for the movie. The Red Sox do enjoy just playing the game. Every team has its issues with players, this year it has gotten public for Sawx. And Yankees as a whole (not every player however) take the game of baseball too seriously. Its just a business and a job for too many of the Yankees players, not a game.

  9. RG says:

    So many typos and other mistakes that it’s hard to read this.

    “The Red Sox can you get any more psychotic then that clubhouse?”

    Even without the then/than switch, what kind of sentence is that?

  10. Well done. While I may have not made the exact comparisons, I can see your points.

    The Orioles as Scarecrow. Tremendous.

  11. D says:

    As a Red Sox fan, I was a more than a little offended that you made the Sox the Joker. However, upon reading what you said about the psychotic players and situations that the Sox have seen, I am inclined to agree with you. I agree that Joker loves to ruin Batman’s day because he’s “fun,” and the same can be said for our love of beating on the Yankees. It’s just too much fun to give up. And he likes being strange and derranged. He enjoys it. So do we. I wouldn’t change any player or his actions on our team. It makes watching baseball very exciting. And it is definitely true that Batman and the Joker are mirrors of eachother in darkness, and that makes your assignment of the Yankees as Batman alright. He may be the hero, but many people really do hate him… the Yankees.

    And it certainly doesn’t hurt that the Joker was played by the wonderful Heath Ledger (R.I.P.) who gave a stunning performance in the movie.

  12. TBayRay Fan in St. Pete says:

    Okay Yankee fan…a little geography lesson for you. The Rays are NOT in TAMPA! They are in St. Petersburg. Tampa Bay is known as a region of seven counties surrounding a body of water known as Tampa Bay. The Rays represent the area, hence the name Tampa Bay Rays. Tampa has the Bucs and the Lightning. St. Petersburg has the Grand Prix (and IRL’s Dan Wheldon), headquarters for the Women’s Tennis Association, home of Winky Wright (belt-holding boxer), HQ of Minor League Baseball and the AL EAST-LEADING TAMPA BAY RAYS! It should be nice for Yankee fans to get October off this season to watch the playoffs from their couches!

  13. […] 5. If the AL East teams were characters from Batman, which characters would they be? [My Sports Rumors] […]

  14. thebostonbuckeye says:

    ok i hate admitting it but that was a great article…although my red sox are not as nutty as you make them out to be (well the fans are but not the players) and of course i think the redsox should be batman (although neither batman nor joker sound all that great) and whatever with tampa! the good guy…HA! GO BOSOX!!!!

  15. none says:

    The Tampa Bay Rays may bring a smile to the face of folks in Tampa, 20+ miles way from the city they play in, but a nod to that city, St. Petersburg, where the team is based, would be nice. 🙂

  16. BaltimoreBird83 says:

    Nice concept for the article.

    I would argue Peter Angelos is the Scarecrow incarnate, driving us O’s fans to insanity through his destructive ownership. The team is playing ‘well’ enough this year to create shivers of .500 ball in my bloodstream.

    Note: I think you meant to use the word “though” instead of “thou”… unless this is a sacred blog. 😉

  17. ontheave77 says:


    You’re such a typical Yanks crank! The team could be stocked with axe-murderers and child molesters and you would still think they were just a bunch of choir boys!

    Go Sox! Go Rays! Yankees? Go to Hell!

  18. Who am I? says:

    First of all– really cool idea.
    Second of all– terribly written.
    Third of all– really cool idea.
    Lastly– The Yankees aren’t crazier than the Red Sox? You only mentioned about a third of all the insanity that happens with the Yankees.

  19. lieigs says:

    You’re retarded.

  20. Ranger_Beauchemin says:

    This was one of the best articles I have ever read! As a HUGE Batman fan and a HUGE Red Sox fan, this was spot on! I even believe that the Sox are equivilant to the Joker because we grew up so messed up…but when the team wins (no matter how crazy it was) it works out to be genius when you take a step back…In our minds we will always be underdogs and would never truly escape the misery we had for so long. And as with the comics, Red Sox baseball just wouldn’t be fun to watch without the Yankees! Even if BOTH teams end up fighting for second-to-last place for all eternity, I truly hope the rivalry never dies!

  21. Dana says:

    This article is riddled with spelling/grammer errors.

    Also… “They’ve got players fighting in the dugout, a player pushing team personnel to the ground, players almost getting arrested while leaving the game for ignoring police officers.” The fight in the dugout? That was Manny trying to hit Youk. Pushing team personnel to the ground? Manny. Almost getting arrested while leaving a game? Yup, you guessed it, it was Manny. But that was for jaywalking and I’m pretty sure the Joker has done far worse things than crossing a street outside of a crosswalk. So by my count, that’s only 1 player. Nice try though.

  22. Boris says:

    Awesome article, even better movie. I’m a yankees fan and I would even go as far as to categorize the sox as the scarecrow, insane due to the lackluster 86 years that will haunt them for their existance. The movie is definently worth seeing twice.

  23. Sharper says:

    Good connections, but next time proof read your work.

  24. Sean says:

    They’ve got players fighting in the dugout, a player pushing team personnel to the ground, players almost getting arrested while leaving the game for ignoring police officers.

    ….that’s pretty much all one guy.

  25. Dave says:

    Interesting concept- I live in The Tampa Bay area,so the comments concerning the area are spot on. My picks.Batman-Tampa Bay Rays Conflicted and haunted by the past,misunderstood by fans. Willing to do what’s right to win. The Joker- Orioles. Power mad owner. A perennial loser to better teams. Two Face- The Jays.Start strong can’t accept defeat. Alfred-NY Yanks Wise old franchise. Knows how to win when all seems bleak. Which leaves Lt. Gordon- BoSaux. Knows His place as a bit player. A win here and there,But can’t measure up to Batman and Alfred. Needs to stage own death over 80 Years.

  26. Yomama says:

    The Red Sox as the Joker? Pretty stupid and unimaginative. I mean come on, the Red Sox the are Joker and the Yanks are Batman? Way too predictable. Obviously they should have been Harvey Dent. They are the White Knight, out to accomplish the same thing as the Dark Knight (Yankees), which is clean up Gotham (win the WS), but only with the blessings and support from the rest of the baseball community (Gotham City). I mean come on, the Yankees are the “Evil Empire,” not the Sox. Like Dent said, “you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain”. And if the Red Sox keep on winning like this they will become baseball’s most infamous villains of all time. The Rays are the Joker because they have definitely pulled the sheets over our eyes when we hardly saw it coming. And like the Joker, they still lack an identity. Paul Raymond, get creative!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  27. Paul Raymond says:

    all depends on your point of view. To me, the Red Sox were never a hero and never will be. But I see your reasoning. Everyone has their own thoughts on this and they are all different. That’s the great thing about this article and all the comments that have followed!

  28. CynicalCustom says:

    Where is Jeffrey Maier in all of this?

  29. […] posts. Something like the Neeko remake of Jay-Z’s Empire State of Mind or even comparing the AL East to the Dark Knight a couple years […]

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these html tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

  • Twitter Updates